Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion
Posted by Island Chris on December 14, 2012 at 09:20:12:

There is a thread below from Nov 28 to December 3. It has gotten a bit too far down (I posted on it a couple hours ago).

Island daughter said that you should remove multiple quakes that occur on one day (leave one) from the total quakes. That would affect Roger's statistics and make Amit's record a little better.

Island Daughter took Biostatistics in the last couple of years, and is a Bio graduate.

We could be wrong; she just looked at this for about 2 minutes. But Amit's argument that if there were some number of M6+ quakes and they all occured on the predicted day, and none occured on unpredicted days, Rogers' approach would not give 100% success if there were multiple quakes in 1 day. Roger did not address this point in my opinion.

Chris


Follow Ups:
     ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Roger Hunter  09:36:41 - 12/14/2012  (80786)  (4)
        ● Roger did not address one of Amit's examples - Island Chris  07:55:30 - 12/16/2012  (80811)  (2)
           ● Re: Roger did not address one of Amit's examples - Skywise  14:31:08 - 12/16/2012  (80822)  (0)
           ● Re: Roger did not address one of Amit's examples - Roger Hunter  08:18:22 - 12/16/2012  (80812)  (1)
              ● Re: Roger did not address one of Amit's examples - Roger Hunter  08:28:29 - 12/16/2012  (80814)  (0)
        ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Roger Hunter  11:05:31 - 12/14/2012  (80789)  (0)
        ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Roger Hunter  11:00:32 - 12/14/2012  (80788)  (0)
        ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Amit  10:58:46 - 12/14/2012  (80787)  (1)
           ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Roger Hunter  11:09:11 - 12/14/2012  (80790)  (1)
              ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Amit  09:44:24 - 12/15/2012  (80796)  (1)
                 ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Amit  10:04:20 - 12/15/2012  (80797)  (1)
                    ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Roger Hunter  12:56:40 - 12/15/2012  (80801)  (1)
                       ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Roger Hunter  19:12:08 - 12/15/2012  (80805)  (1)
                          ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Amit  00:05:13 - 12/16/2012  (80806)  (1)
                             ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Amit  00:37:20 - 12/16/2012  (80807)  (1)
                                ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Amit  07:19:05 - 12/16/2012  (80808)  (1)
                                   ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Roger Hunter  07:31:43 - 12/16/2012  (80809)  (1)
                                      ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Amit  07:45:06 - 12/16/2012  (80810)  (1)
                                         ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Roger Hunter  08:48:33 - 12/16/2012  (80815)  (1)
                                            ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Amit  08:53:54 - 12/16/2012  (80816)  (1)
                                               ● Re: Island daughter and Amit-Roger discussion - Roger Hunter  09:03:46 - 12/16/2012  (80817)  (0)