Question is...
Posted by Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande on November 11, 2006 at 07:47:07:

"A 4.5 mag earthquake near Lake Tahoe has a greater significance than a 4.5 near Tonga."

No argument from me, there, Glen. But, without seeing the original, unedited prediction, and with some knowledge of the predictor's methodology, some of us are extremely skeptical. And, I doubt that the prediction was limited to Lake Tahoe, so it is disingenous to now argue that solely Lake Tahoe's seismicity is important here. With so little to get our teeth into here, a reasonable reference to the extremely high rate of such quakes globally is not uncalled-for.

Michael F. Williams
Arroyo Grande, CA USA


Follow Ups:
     ● Re: Question is... Tahoe -Mike - Cal  22:58:46 - 11/11/2006  (60092)  (1)
        ● Re: Question is... Tahoe -Mike  - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  06:43:39 - 11/12/2006  (60103)  (1)
           ● Tahoe Seismicity Link Here - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  06:45:42 - 11/12/2006  (60104)  (1)
              ● Re: Tahoe Seismicity Link Here--Mike - Cal  10:00:10 - 11/12/2006  (60106)  (1)
                 ● Re: Tahoe Seismicity Link Here--Mike - Skywise  20:50:08 - 11/12/2006  (60121)  (1)
                    ● no evidence I could find - John Vidale  23:18:43 - 11/12/2006  (60122)  (3)
                       ● Re: no evidence I could findJohn - cal  09:57:10 - 11/13/2006  (60142)  (1)
                          ● Re: no evidence I could findJohn - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  10:45:54 - 11/13/2006  (60144)  (1)
                             ● Re: no evidence I could findJohn - Skywise  16:01:33 - 11/13/2006  (60156)  (1)
                                ● Re: no evidence I could findJohn - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  17:33:55 - 11/13/2006  (60157)  (1)
                                   ● Re: no evidence I could findJohn - Roger Hunter  17:52:02 - 11/13/2006  (60162)  (1)
                                      ● Re: no evidence I could findJohn - Skywise  18:40:04 - 11/13/2006  (60164)  (1)
                                         ● keep it here - heartland chris  06:49:12 - 11/14/2006  (60203)  (0)
                       ● Re: no evidence I could find--John  - Cal  09:45:44 - 11/13/2006  (60133)  (1)
                          ● I found that article, too - John Vidale  18:45:28 - 11/13/2006  (60165)  (0)
                       ● 1975China - heartland chris  06:39:21 - 11/13/2006  (60129)  (1)
                          ● good article this year on 1975 quake - John Vidale  08:40:25 - 11/13/2006  (60132)  (1)
                             ● Re: good article this year on 1975  - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  10:31:21 - 11/13/2006  (60143)  (1)
                                ● their summary, not mine - John Vidale  19:16:33 - 11/13/2006  (60172)  (0)