waffling
Posted by John Vidale on September 10, 2006 at 08:15:48:

This post illustrates the contortions necessary to defend the claims of Jim and Cal.

Now, it's necessary to "dumb down for the mainstream audiences", and the warnings are useful "just in case a quake does hit".

As opposed to the strident claims that Jim and Cal possess knowledge mainstream scientists are too blind to see, knowledge that would save lives, knowledge that is contradicted by every careful study, which appear in other posts and are the centerpiece of the book.

In combination with the statements that Cal loves the notoriety ("why else did the science editor focus on me?" as they also do on the health benefits of vinegar, on astrology, on medical treatment by leeches, ... ) it is clear the main goal here is to sell books and be famous, not enlighten the people in need of the facts about earthquakes.

Personally, I enjoyed the book, but it is not a science document except where it reviews what the scientists have already known for many years.


Follow Ups:
     ● Gulf Of Mexico M6.0 - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  16:19:46 - 9/10/2006  (291)  (2)
        ● east coast quakes - John Vidale  18:12:24 - 9/10/2006  (295)  (1)
           ● Re: east coast quakes - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  22:18:41 - 9/10/2006  (297)  (1)
              ● flatlands - John Vidale  23:51:16 - 9/10/2006  (300)  (0)
        ● Correction:Gulf of Mexico Post - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  16:21:18 - 9/10/2006  (292)  (0)
     ● Re: waffling--to Vidale - Cal  13:02:42 - 9/10/2006  (289)  (2)
        ● Re: waffling--to Vidale - Skywise  21:01:34 - 9/10/2006  (296)  (2)
           ● Re: waffling--to Skywise - Cal  11:34:52 - 9/11/2006  (315)  (1)
              ● Re: waffling--to Skywise - Skywise  20:22:05 - 9/11/2006  (40501)  (1)
                 ● Re: waffling--to Skywise - Skywise  21:35:23 - 9/13/2006  (40536)  (0)
           ● Re: waffling--to Vidale - Roger Hunter  22:30:55 - 9/10/2006  (298)  (1)
              ● Re: waffling--to Vidale - Skywise  23:18:26 - 9/10/2006  (299)  (1)
                 ● Re: waffling--to Vidale - Cathryn  00:31:28 - 9/11/2006  (301)  (1)
                    ● Re: waffling--to Vidale - Roger Hunter  08:39:35 - 9/11/2006  (308)  (1)
                       ● Re: waffling--to Vidale - Cathryn  20:48:53 - 9/11/2006  (40503)  (0)
        ● one quake at a time - John Vidale  14:57:58 - 9/10/2006  (290)  (0)