not an expert
Posted by John Vidale on May 23, 2006 at 00:15:50:

Plagiarism is not a big issue among research publications in seismology. It's a small field, and if someone copied someone else's words, it would be easy to detect and prove. I don't think I've ever heard of a case. It's a non-issue.

In other fields, occasional cases have arisen, more likely go undetected, but still its quite uncommon.

On the other hand, people frequently suspect others have taken their ideas without proper credit. My attitude is that ideas are cheap, proving them is difficult. And many think their ideas are so clever that no one else could have thought of them, but we're really not all that much cleverer than each other. And frankly, I'm more interested in new ideas than their history.

Not sure if this addresses your question.

John


Follow Ups:
     ● rock em & roll - John Vidale  00:29:30 - 5/23/2006  (37198)  (2)
        ● Re: rock em & roll - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  13:37:49 - 5/23/2006  (37237)  (1)
           ● rock em & roll - John Vidale  14:20:12 - 5/23/2006  (37240)  (2)
              ● Re: rock em & roll - Glen  05:09:17 - 5/24/2006  (37265)  (1)
                 ● Re: rock em & roll - Thank You - Petra  10:15:52 - 5/24/2006  (37273)  (1)
                    ● Re: rock em & roll - Thank You - Cathryn  23:48:52 - 5/24/2006  (37328)  (1)
                       ● Re: rock em & roll - Thank You - Roger Hunter  07:01:45 - 5/25/2006  (37342)  (1)
                          ● Re: rock em & roll - Thank You - Cathryn  10:16:51 - 5/25/2006  (37354)  (0)
              ● Thanks John (N/T) - Mike Williams in Arroyo Grande  15:44:54 - 5/23/2006  (37249)  (1)
                 ● Re: Thanks John (N/T) - Glen  17:31:45 - 5/23/2006  (37251)  (0)
        ● Appreciated - Glen  01:00:46 - 5/23/2006  (37199)  (1)
           ● The Cut Throat Flip Side - Petra  10:19:17 - 5/23/2006  (37213)  (1)
              ● Re: The Cut Throat Flip Side - Glen  11:45:30 - 5/23/2006  (37215)  (1)
                 ● Re: The Cut Throat Flip Side - Petra  12:18:55 - 5/23/2006  (37216)  (0)