Petra,

You may be right that all the evidence is in the archives,
or I may be right that the postings are too loose to definitively evaluate or may fail to support the claims.

One last difference of opinion - I don't mind the approach of geoForecasters, whatever it is, I just doubt it works and am frustrated it is asserted to work, kept a secret, and clouded in dubious statistics.

We do seem to have a common goal, attempting to
predict earthquakes, the possibility of which is still an open question.

John