Posted by Lowell on October 31, 2001 at 11:07:52:
FAR-FIELD AFTERSHOCK FORECAST FOR NEW BRITAIN MW 7.0 (PRELIMINARY) (OCTOBER 31, 2001) A strong Mw 7.0 earthquake occurred in the easatern New Britain region this morning shortly after a strong M3.4 class solar flare about half an hour earlier. As this report will show, the region was in the cross-hairs of tidal, far-field and geomagnetic triggering at this time, so this event and it's timing should not come as a surprise to those who follow these phenomena. NEIS and GSSR give the event parameters as: O: 31Oct2001 09:10:19 4.9S 149.8E MW=7.0 NEIS NEW BRITAIN REGION, P.N.G O: 31Oct2001 09:10:15 6.5S 150.6E MS=6.5 GSSR NEW BRITAIN REGION, P.N.G SEISMIC HISTORY OF AREA: Twenty-two earthquakes of Mw>=7 have occurred in the last century within 200 km of today's epicenter. The largest was a Mw 8.4 on September 14, 1906 followed by a Mw 7.7 aftershock on Oct. 2, 1906. Large events in this area often occur in pairs or groups with the first event small, leading to larger event(s). For example see events in 1905, 1906, 1945, 1949, and 1999 in Table 1. Of 14 groupings, five have had multiple events of Mw>=7, so the chance of a second event in this magnitude range in this area is about one-third. Odds of one in three. The region is sparsely populated, so only minor damage is expected. Tsunamis often occur with earthquakes of this size in this region, but will probably be less than 1 m runup if they occurs. Table 1 lists the parameters of earthquake of Mw>=7 within 200 km of today's NEIC epicenter. Table 1: Seismicity within 200 km of 4.9S 149.8E (Ms>=7) MO DA HR MN SC YEAR S LATIT E LONG DEPT MW 3 4 16 0 20 1905 4.000S 149.000E 60 7.1 3 4 23 17 30 1905 4.000S 149.000E 60 7.2 5 18 13 45 6 1905 4.000S 149.000E 60 7.5 8 26 5 59 31 1906 4.000S 149.000E 60 7.4 9 14 0 0 0 1906 6.000S 150.000E 0 8.4 9 17 8 38 0 1906 4.000S 149.000E 60 7.1 10 2 2 52 0 1906 4.000S 149.000E 60 7.7 9 7 7 11 18 1910 6.000S 151.000E 80 7.3 11 2 21 8 6 1923 4.500S 151.500E 50 7.2 6 11 0 49 35 1930 5.500S 150.000E 60 7.1 2 28 14 21 42 1934 5.000S 150.000E 60 7.2 12 27 4 41 5 1945 6.000S 151.000E 40 7.0 12 28 17 48 45 1945 6.000S 150.000E 60 7.8 3 16 22 15 13 1949 5.500S 151.000E 60 7.0 3 17 21 5 3 1949 5.500S 151.000E 60 7.0 11 17 8 15 39 1964 5.700S 150.700E 45 7.6 5 30 7 49 43 1984 4.700S 151.800E 169 7.1 5 10 15 35 51 1985 5.599S 151.045E 27 7.3 10 16 20 47 58 1987 6.000S 149.100E 24 7.1 9 28 20 26 56 1991 5.814S 150.959E 28 7.1 4 5 11 8 4 1999 5.591S 149.568E 150 7.4 5 10 20 33 2 1999 5.159S 150.880E 138 7.1 FAR-FIELD TRIGGERING:
The area had been identified as a region subject to Far-field aftershocks (FFA) from the Ms 6.8 in New Zealand on 21 October, 2001 (that forecast expires tomorrow). The forecast had stated: From Guam: "17-19 degrees: ...East Papua New Guinea" and "Areas which have had several occurrences of unusual earthquakes following such events include: ...Papua New Guinea/New Britain/Admiralty Islands" and "43-45 degrees: Papua New Guinea, Bismarck Sea, New Ireland," This event is 42-43 degrees from the Banda epicenter (depending on which determination is used). The epicentral region was probably also affected by the Kamchatka (October 8) and the Guam earthquakes (October 12). This earthquake is located at 18 degrees from Guam and 59 degrees from Kamchatka, both distances where FFA area expected. The far-field forecasts from those events had stated: From Guam: "17-19 degrees: ...East Papua New Guinea" and "Secondary location where event tend to occur but are not as large or as likely . MB>=4.8 considered likely in next 10 days. ....New Britain" And from Kamchatka: "The most likely events of M>=5 in the next 10 days on the basis of history and far-field triggering theory appear to be: Papua, ... New Guinea" and "59-61 degrees: ... Solomon Isl./New Britain/Papua" TIDAL TRIGGERING The New Britain/Solomon Islands had been identified in yesterday's report (October 30, 2001) as an area where seismicity is statistically correlated with this day of the lunar month. The region has shown a 26% rate increase in events of Mb>=4 on this day of the lunar cycle over the past 100 years. This is a highly significant (at 0.03 level) increase in seismicity. That report had given the following statistics for the area for tidal triggering in the region today (October 31, 2001): "Region Magnitude range %change z-value Significance level ... Solomon Islands MB>=4.0 26 2.6 0.03" SOLAR/GEOMAGNETICS EFFECTS:
The earthquake may have been immediately triggered effects from an M-Class solar flare which occurred during hour prior to the earthquake. SEC gives the flare the following parameters: Flare # START MAX END CLASS 9180 + 0734 0809 0819 M3.2 This is the largest observed flare since an M6.5 on October 22 and an M3.6 on October 28. The area was also under a seismic watch for larger events due to the CME and resulting geomagnetic storm of October 28. A special warning had been issued on that watch which stated (on Oct. 28): "The CME arrival was followed quickly by a strong sudden commencement geomagnetic storm. The storm started at 03:21 UT. Anti-solar areas are within 20 degrees longitude of 50W; subsolar regions within 20 degrees of 130E. This includes most of the western Pacific region and the eastern Caribbean Sea. These areas will be under seismic watch conditions for the next two days. LARGER ASSOCIATED EVENTS ARE LIKE TO OCCUR FROM OCTOBER 31-NOVEMBER 2" [emphasis added] This watch/warning was repeated in the daily report from October 28, 2001. This epicenter lies with 20 degrees longitude of 130 E and therefore was subject to this seismic watch. New Britain also lies near the geomagnetic equator, an area where delayed triggering effects from geomagnetic storms are expected to be enhanced due to the equatorial electrojets. The combination of tidal, pulse, geomagnetic and far-field triggering was probably sufficient to trigger this large earthquake.
Seismicity is expected to increase in areas where seismic energy from the great shocks is concentrated due to internal reflections and refractions of waves off internal boundaries. Following are the locations and distances where this is expected to occur. Triggered activity in these regions appears likely from 31 October through 10 November. Maximum event size for these regions is expected to increase by 0.8 magnitude units in this period. 0-5 degrees: Regional triggering- Bismarck Sea, New Britain, New Ireland, eastern Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, Admiralty Islands. 9-10 degrees: West Irian (about 140E), Solomon Islands (about 160E) 17-19 degrees: Santa Cruz Isl, Vanuatu (about 15-16S), Ceram, Guam 34-36 degrees: So. of Bali/Java, Luzon, Philippines, Ryukyu Isl. SE of Honshu (around 30-32N 141E), Samoa/No. Tonga Islands 43-45 degrees: South of Sumatera (about 5-7S, 103-105E), North of Tokyo E. Coast of Honshu (36-38N, 140-142E), most of North and South Island, New Zealand, 59-61 degrees: Andaman Is., Myanmar, Kamchatka, Central Aleutians, Hawaii 71-73 degrees: Nepal, Alaska Peninsula, 103-107 degrees***: Central, eastern Turkey, Caucasus, Michoacan/Jalisco Mexico, Central Plains, U.S. 142-146 degrees: Virgin Island, Azores, Puerto Rico 176-180 degrees: Central Mid-Atlantic Ridge (Seismic area 5N 30W-32W) ***: The strongest triggering is always expected to be along the shadow zone boundary between 103-107 degrees from the epicenter. Historical following quakes after large events in the Guam region: MAIN MAR 4 1905 4.0S 149.0E 60 7.1 MAIN MAR 4 1905 4.0S 149.0E 60 7.2 AFTEREVENTS Mar 04 43N 72W M VI New York State Mar 05 33N 80W Ml 2.7 South Carolina Mar 13 45N 87W Ml 4.3 North of Chicago, ILL Mar 14 40N 76E M 6.2 Xinjiang, China MAIN MAY 18 1905 4.0S 149.0E 60 7.5 AFTEREVENTS May 22 0N 79W M 6.2 Ecuador May 30 46N 16E Ml 5.2 Austria Jun 01 42N 20E M 6.6 No. Greece/Bulgaria/Albania MAIN AUG 26 1906 4.0S 149.0E 60 7.4 AFTEREVENTS
Aug 28 44N 19E Ml 4.0 Austria/Hungary Aug 29 42N 18E Ml 5.2 Albania Aug 39 21S 70W M 7.2 Northern Chile Aug 31 27N 97E M 7.0 Southern China Sep 07 38N 87W M 3.8 Indiana/Kentucky Sep 07 34N 141E M 7.1 Off E. Coast Honshu MAIN SEP 14 1906 6.0S 150.0E 0 8.4 MAIN SEP 17 1906 4.0S 149.0E 60 7.1 AFTEREVENTS Sep 17 41N 20E Ml 4.4 Northern Greece/Albania Sep 20 45N 18E Ml 4.7 Austria/Hungary Sep 28 40N 42E M 6.2 Easatern Turkey Sep 28 2S 79E M 7.9 Ecuador MAIN OCT 2 1906 4.0S 149.0E 60 7.7 AFTEREVENTS Oct 02 44N 18E Ml 4.7 Austria/Hungary Oct 04 37N 68E M 5.7 Afghanistan Oct 08 53N 155E M 7.0 Kamchatka Oct 11 40N 140E Ml 5.6 So. of Hokkaido, Japan Oct 13 39N 76W Ml 2.7 No. Virginia Oct 12 34N 107E Ml III New Mexico Oct 16 46N 27E M 5.5 Romania Oct 18 19N 121E M 7.3 Taiwan Oct 20 41N 43 M 5.4 Eastern Turkey MAIN SEP 7 1910 6.0S 151.0E 80 7.3
AFTEREVENTS Sep 09 51N 179W M 7.3 Central Aleutians Sep 12 33N 80W Ml 2.7 So. Carolina Sep 24 17N 96W M 7.1 Oaxaca Mexico MAIN NOV 2 1923 4.5S 151.5E 50 7.2 MAIN NOV 3 1923 5.0S 152.0E 60 7.2
AFTEREVENTS Nov 03 19N 73W M 6.0 No. of Haiti Nov 03 30N 131E M 6.8 Kyushu, Japan (swarm including 7.1 on 11-5) Nov 04 36N 139E M 6.3 Off E. Coast Honshu Nov 06 33N 116E M 5.0 Anza, So. California Nov 07 38S 73W M 6.3 Southern Chile Nov 07 33N 116E M 6.3 Anza, So. California Nov 11 40N 90W Ml 4.2 SW of Chicago, Ill Nov 16 53N 133W Ms 5.0 Queen Charlotte Isl. B.C. Nov 17 36N 141E Ms 6.3 Off E Coast, Honshu MAIN JUN 11 1930 5.5S 150.0E 60 7.1
AFTEREVENTS Jun 11 25N 94E M 5.0 Myanmar Jun 12 19N 155W Ml 5.0 Hawaii Jun 12 43N 111W Ml 5.8 Jackson Lake area, Wyoming Jun 15 46S 116W Ml 6.3 So. East Pacific Rise Jun 26 19N 64W M 6.3 Virgin Islands MAIN FEB 28 1934 5.0S 150.0E 60 7.2
AFTEREVENTS Mar 01 7S 148E M 6.5 Papua New Guinea Mar 01 40S 71W M 7.1 So. Chile Mar 02 33N 116E Ml 4.5 Southern California (swarm in Anza area) Mar 03 34N 118E Ml 3.5 So. California (So. of L.A.) Mar 04 16S 168E M 6.3 Vanuatu Islands Mar 04 56N 164E M 6.3 Komandorsky Islands Mar 05 40S 175E Ms 7.5 North Island N.Z. (near Wellington) Mar 07 13N 87W Ms 6.3 El Salvador area Mar 12 41N 113W Ms 6.6 Utah Mar 13 11S 164E Ms 6.8 Santa Cruz Islands MAIN DEC 27 1945 6.0S 151.0E 40 7.0 MAIN DEC 28 1945 6.0S 150.0E 60 7.8
AFTEREVENTS Dec 28 44N 71W Ml 2.3 Eastern New York Jan 05 15N 91W M 6.0 Guatemala/Chiapas border Jan 05 16S 167E M 7.3 Central Vanuatu Islands Jan 08 33N 116W Ml 5.4 Southern California (Anza) Jan 10 44N 130E Ml 7.2 Sea of Japan Jan 13 59N 147W M 7.2 South of Alaska Jan 13 37N 118W Ml 4.7 Mammoth Lakes, California MAIN MAR 16 1949 5.5S 151.0E 60 7.0 MAIN MAR 17 1949 5.5S 151.0E 60 7.0
AFTEREVENTS Mar 19 31N 131E M 6.0 Kyushu Mar 17 33N 116W Ml 3.7 Southern California (Anza) Mar 20 35N 117E Ml 4.4 China Lake, California Mar 24 42N 126W M 6.2 Off Coast No. California Mar 25 42N 126W M 6.2 Off Coast No. California Mar 27 3N 127W M 7.0 Molucca Mar 30 49N 128W Ml 4.8 Vancouver, B.C. Mar 22 44N 129W Ms 6.8 OFf Coast of Oregon MAIN NOV 17 1964 5.7S 150.7E 45 7.6 MAIN NOV 19 1964 6.0S 150.7E 45 7.0 AFTEREVENTS Nov 17 44N 111W Ml 3.9 Yellowstone Nov 17 33N 116W Ml 4.5 Southern California (Anza) Nov 17 41N 74W Ml 4.3 New York City Nov 18 20S 174W Ml 6.0 Tonga/Samoa Nov 20 5S 145E M 6.0 Papua New Guinea Nov 20 44N 150E Ml 5.5 Kuril Islands Nov 24 6S 107W Ms 6.0 South of Sumatera Nov 24 13N 124E Ms 6.7 Luzon, Philippines Nov 25 4S 122E Ms 6.2 Banda Sea Nov 26 24S 124E Ms 6.4 Taiwan MAIN MAY 30 1984 4.7S 151.8E 169 7.1
AFTEREVENTS Jun 06 4S 125E Ms 5.9 Banda Sea Jun 07 5S 104E Ms 6.0 South of Sumatera Jun 11 30S 71W Ml 6.3 Central Chile MAIN MAY 10 1985 5.5S 151.0E 27 7.3 AFTEREVENTS May 10 34N 121W Ml 3.8 Southern California (triggered by P-arrival) May 10 43N 20E Ml 5.2 Yugoslavia May 11 36N 120E Ml 4.0 Coalinga, Central California May 11 37N 141E MB 5.5 Off E. Coast Honshu May 12 16N 120E MB 5.4 Luzon, Philippines May 13 33N 133E MB 5.7 Shikoku, Japan May 14 10S 41E Ms 6.4 Madagascar May 15 56S 25W Ms 6.4 So. Sndwich Islands May 16 29S 77E Ms 6.1 Mid-Indian Rise May 19 30S 71W Ms 6.0 Central Chile May 20 35N 87E Ms 6.0 Tibet MAIN OCT 16 1987 6.0S 149.1E 24 7.1
AFTEREVENTS Oct 19 40N 111W Ml 3.9 Utah Oct 22 37N 122W Ml 4.4 Central California Oct 25 5N 36E M 6.2 Ethiopia Oct 25 2S 138E MS 7.0 West Irian Oct 26 41N 113W Ml 4.8 Utah MAIN SEP 28 1991 5.8S 150.9E 28 7.1
AFTEREVENTS Sep 30 20S 178W M 6.3 Tonga/Fiji Sep 30 43N 71W Ml 2.7 Southern New England Oct 03 36N 90W Ml 3.0 New Madrid Oct 03 17S 167E M 5.7 So. Vanuatu Isl. Oct 05 46N 13E Ml 4.5 Austria MAIN APR 5 1999 5.5S 149.5E 150 7.4
Apr 05 24N 94E Ml 5.6 Myanmarka Apr 06 39N 38E M 5.1 Central Turkey Apr 06 41N 108E Ml 4.3 Wyoming (Rock Springs area) Apr 06 24N 48W MW 5.9 Northern Mid-Atlantic ridge Apr 06 6S 147E MW 6.4 Papua New Guinea Apr 07 33N 116E Ml 4.0 Southern California Apr 08 43N 130E Ms 7.1 Russia/China border Apr 09 42S 84E Ms 5.6 Southeast Indian Rise Apr 09 26S 178E Ms 6.1 South of Fiji Islands Apr 12 20S 168E Ms 5.7 Loyalty Islands Apr 13 21S 176W Ms 6.8 Fiji/Tonga area Apr 13 53N 163W Ms 5.1 Alaska Peninsula/Unimak Apr 17 19N 155W Ms 5.6 Hawaii MAIN MAY 10 1999 5.1S 150.8E 138 7.1 MAIN MAY 16 1999 4.8S 152.5E 74 7.1 AFTEREVENTS May 10 36S 110W Mw 6.0 South east Pacific Rise followed by swarm May 11 54N 165W M 5.4 Fox Islands May 12 43N 143E Mw 6.2 Hokkaido, Japan May 14 34N 116W Ml 4.9 Southern California (Landers area) May 14 3S 130E Ml 5.5 Seram May 15 4S 102E Ml 5.2 South of Sumatera May 15 37N 118W MW 5.6 Mammoth Lakes, California May 16 3S 138E MW 6.2 Irian Jaya May 18 39S 175E MW 5.8 North Island, New Zealand May 21 60S 24W MW 5.7 South Sandwich Islands May 22 20S 169E MW 6.0 Vanuatu Islands May 27 15S 120E MW 5.5 Luzon, Philippines May 27 58N 137W MW 5.6 SE Alaska Summary of far-field events following New Britain mainshocks:
In general, the events of Mb>=5 tend to fall in the areas described by the listing of far-field events expected above from distance considerations. The most likely events of Mw>=6 in the next 10 days appear to be: Central Vanuatu Islands Off East Coast of Honshu, or Hokkaido, Japan Ecuador Papua New Guinea/West Irian Banda Sea Samoa/Tonga/Foko Central Chile The most likely events of M>=5 in the next 10 days on the basis of history and far-field triggering theory appear to be: South of Sumatera/Java Luzon, Philippines Myanmar Shikoku/Kyushu Japan Taiwan Austria/Hungary/Yugoslavia area Central Aleutians South of Alaska Virgin Islands to Haiti Secondary location where event tend to occur but are not as large or as likely . MB>=4.8 considered likely in next 10 days. South Sandwich Islands North Island, New Zealand Central Turkey Southern Chile Santa Cruz Islands Areas of U.S. and Canada where triggering may occur (Ml>=4.0) Hawaii Central Andreanoff Islands Off the Coast of California and Oregon Southern California - esp. in Anza and area to south Utah around 41N 111-113W Vancouver Island SE Alaska Areas of U.S. and Canada where triggering may occur (Ml>=3 or unusual events) New England/esp. Eastern New York State Area surrounding Chicago Ill./ great plains states Indiana/Kentucky/Virginia Unusual events may occur in Madagascar Ethiopia There is a strong relationship between New Britain events and succeeding earthquake in southern California especially in the area of Anza to the Salton Sea. This is probably because wave fronts from New Britain arrive approximately parallel to the San Andreas in this region, promoting larger events. This area should remain active for several week. A larger event in this area often occurs 28-33 or 43-46 days after the event in New Britain, so the danger is not yet over.
Follow Ups:
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain - Canie 12:39:16 - 10/31/2001 (10543) (1)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain - Lowell 16:43:15 - 11/3/2001 (10663) (0)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - michael 11:46:31 - 10/31/2001 (10541) (2)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - Lowell 16:47:13 - 11/3/2001 (10664) (0)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - Roger Hunter 11:56:04 - 10/31/2001 (10542) (1)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - michael 15:46:39 - 10/31/2001 (10553) (3)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - Lowell 16:49:43 - 11/3/2001 (10665) (0)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - Roger Hunter 19:03:36 - 10/31/2001 (10558) (0)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - Don In Hollister 16:19:42 - 10/31/2001 (10556) (1)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - michael 12:15:21 - 11/1/2001 (10571) (2)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - Lowell 16:52:48 - 11/3/2001 (10666) (0)
● Re: Far Field Aftershock Forecast from New Britain (10-31-01) - Roger Hunter 12:31:33 - 11/1/2001 (10573) (0)
|