It isn't amazing in the slightest. It's like predicting a magnitude 2 in New York and getting a magnitude 5 in Quebec. Totally different in scale and location.

Or to try and put in a different perspective: if I predicted "a small mammal" was going to appear in my street tomorrow (with every expectation of seeing a cat), and instead an elephant escaped from a circus the other side of town, would you say I'd made an "amazing call" then?