try talking to Freund, he makes little sense
Posted by John Vidale on January 24, 2005 at 21:19:10:

He is employed by NASA, for what I don't know. Yes, if you hit a rock with a projectile at 6 km/s some energy will go into all kinds of waves. That is near the speed that the Earth is orbiting the Sun, i.e., extrordinarily fast. What does this have to do with earthquakes? Particle velocity (the speed at which the sides of the fault slip) is about 1 m/s, almost four orders of magnitude less.

Do you realize rock vaporizes at those impact velocities? Probably turns entirely to plasma for all I know.


Follow Ups:
     ● Re: try talking to Freund, he makes little sense - Petra  22:04:29 - 1/24/2005  (24578)  (1)
        ● he's both places - John Vidale  22:30:26 - 1/24/2005  (24579)  (1)
           ● Re: he's both places - Petra  22:55:02 - 1/24/2005  (24580)  (1)
              ● sound is a "thunk" - chris in suburbia  03:53:50 - 1/25/2005  (24583)  (3)
                 ● humming deserts - chris in suburbia  05:13:45 - 1/26/2005  (24598)  (1)
                    ● Re: humming deserts - Canie  08:49:10 - 1/26/2005  (24601)  (0)
                 ● Quarks and Black Holes - Petra  17:53:09 - 1/25/2005  (24593)  (1)
                    ● Re: Quarks and Black Holes - Don in Hollister  20:44:31 - 1/25/2005  (24595)  (0)
                 ● Re: sound is a "thunk" - Don in Hollister  04:46:03 - 1/25/2005  (24586)  (2)
                    ● Re: sound is a "thunk" O/T - DH  09:05:18 - 1/25/2005  (24589)  (1)
                       ● Re: sound is a "thunk" O/T - Don in Hollister  10:49:35 - 1/25/2005  (24591)  (0)
                    ● Re: sound is a "thunk" - Cathryn  05:50:44 - 1/25/2005  (24588)  (0)