Posted by Lowell on June 21, 2001 at 07:51:25:
Don, I wonder if you have been watching the BGS web site. There was a Ml 1.8 recorded there yesterday within 80 km of your advisory on an earthquake in Wales. If Roger Musson is right and the incidence of events of this size in the area is about 1 per year, then your odds of getting this within a 10-day window are about 1 in 36. (See Roger Musson's reply to your prediction (#7857 and #7875). A search of our data base (which is quite incomplete for this area) shows this rate is reasonable. Since you did not put a time frame on your advisory, it is impossible to evaluate it completely, however getting it correct within 10 days does beat the odds. BGS website: http://www.gsrg.nmh.ac.uk/recbrit.html Following is the BGS listing: Year Mo Dy Hr Mn Secs Lat Lon kmE kmN Depth Mag Locality 2001 06 20 11 45 14.6 51.948 -3.089 325.1 228.4 28.8 1.8 TALGARTH,POWYS Your advisory (reproduced here) identifies a site which is 68 km from this located epicenter within 10 days and the listed earthquake falls withing the stated magnitude range. Great Britain Posted by Don in Hollister on June 04, 2001 at 14:25:07: Hi All. This is not an earthquakes forecast per say. Lets just say I'm speculating about these. I know it will be a very lucky long shot to even get one in the neighborhood. 52.5N 3.4W 06/09/01---0.9Ml-2.9Ml 52.5N 3.5W 06/08/01---0.9Ml-2.5Ml 52.5N 3.5W 06/09/01---0.9Ml-2.5Ml 52.5N 3.5W 06/10.01---0.9Ml-2.5Ml The radius for all quakes will be 80K. The nearest named point is Trefeglwys which is located in western Great Britain not to far from the coast. And Roger Musson's estimate of occurrence rate: Posted by Roger Musson on June 05, 2001 at 09:57:17: Don's prediction names a tiny Welsh village, but then gives an error radius of 80 km that takes in most of Wales. Well, I suppose that's playing by the rules, it just looks odd. Time window? Is it just for those days? I can't guarantee that anything less than 2.0 would even be recorded, and only the upper end of Don's magnitude range would be felt. The average occurrence rate of magnitude 2+ events within the 80 km circle is probably about 1 per year.
Follow Ups:
● Re: British (Wales) earthquake - Don in Hollister 09:01:53 - 6/21/2001 (8070) (0)
|