Re: 2006 Book on this issue
Posted by heartland chris on January 03, 2009 at 08:14:46:

Penny, I have not seen this book. But, I suspect it was not as scientically rigorous (is that a word?) as the new publication and the open access publication that Dennis linked to. These articles had to make it through review by experts in the field so have more credibility. I suppose you know this already. I had encountered some early stuff by Firestone and/or West that was fairly implausible. Kennett and Kennett joining that team gave it a lot of credibility...father Kennett (J.P.) is in the National Academy or something like that.
On the other hand, getting an article through review is no guarantee that it is correct.
Chris


Follow Ups:
     ● Re: 2006 Book on this issue - PennyB  10:51:02 - 1/3/2009  (74664)  (0)