Re: 3.1 and 4.4
Posted by Russell on May 17, 2006 at 22:27:17:

Petra:

The quakes were just north of you and I think it ludicrous that you would talk to me about being "a little shy on details".

Its a little fraudulent to talk here about how acurate your group is with the ear tones and how much success you're having and yet refuse to post your predictions here. Canie created a nice database to house the data on the tones themselves, yet you and your group refuse to use it.

Your justification for refusing is that people steal your data. Honestly, I think it has more to do with your unwillingness to pre-post data that might cause your theory to be proven innacurate. Apparently its more fun to be able to ramble on about your success without acutally ever having to prove or provide a solid basis for your claims.

Its also disingenious of you to go on about all the abuse you get at the hands of certain people when you are so free with your claims of success. For one, I get a little tired of you thinking you should have it both ways. All the conspiracy theories and all the claims of data theft and all the drama are a little ridiculous at times. Especially when I believe there are several of us skeptics here who would love to see and learn more about this to know whether or not there is something to it.

Petra, I've never read anything here from anyone attacking you - unless you consider a question or a disagreement to be an attack. That type of response usually comes from someone who is inwardly insecure about claims they've made or postions they've taken.

As I've said before, its one thing for you to say "We think something's up, we don't know but we're testing and researching." It would be fair then to say "wait for our results" - as Roger has said. That's acceptable and I - along with others can be patient for the results.

Its another thing altogether to say "We are so accurate and we have such and such success rate and there's no question about the ear tone/eq connection and the scientists are refusing to listen to me and someday I'm going to save the world." Aren't you OBLIGATED to back those types of statments up with FACTS? I think you are and still you don't. Yet, anybody who calls you on the carpet for it is accused of attacking you and your group. To me that's a sign that you know you're spouting nonsense and all your other claims are a smokescreen so you can keep spouting nonsense like its fact.

Anyway, enough of my opinions. I am glad you're out of the hospital and out of danger. I'd miss your maddening and highly questionable and sometimes totally irellevant posts. I'd also miss being the rock in the shoe of your nonsense.

Russell


Follow Ups:
     ● Re: 3.1 and 4.4 - FORMAL COMPLAINT BEING FILED NOW! - Petra  01:05:11 - 5/18/2006  (36983)  (0)