Shan wrote to Roger:

"you have deviated your evaluation process. I suspect that you have given two types
of evaluations, i.e. one for Asian and one for non-Asian..?"

You have got to be kidding. I find this highly offensive. The facts don't lie, and if you go back and look carefully, you will see that Roger goes to extraordinary lengths to be impartial.

I agree with him and Lowell that your prediction was not even close. It has nothing to do with being Asian or non-Asian.

I think you owe Roger an apology.

Cathryn, mother of five children, three of whom are Asian (from Vietnam, India, and Cambodia). Hey, let's throw in Don's Japanese wife and really get down.